
Brokers / Research
Eightcap vs Tickmill for MT5 Expert Advisors: costs, rules and entities
Editorial layout updated 17 November 2026 · Source-check dates remain stated in the article.
Marked Referral links may earn QuantKit a commission. How we’re paid. Payment does not determine our findings.
On this page
Short answerKey facts at a glanceHow do Eightcap Raw and Tickmill Raw costs compare?What is the break-even at EA trading volumes?How do swaps and holding costs compare?How do EA rules and platforms compare?Which legal entity holds your account?What we couldn't confirmWhat should you do next?FAQSources and methodRelated researchShort answer
On a USD Raw account, Tickmill's commission is $1.00 per lot round turn lower than Eightcap's ($6.00 vs $7.00, verified 22 November 2026), and Tickmill carries a graded EUR/USD all-in of $7.00 per lot in QuantKit's cost ledger (v1.0, 15 October 2026). Because Eightcap does not yet have an accepted average spread under QuantKit's grading method, this comparison names the break-even rather than a cheaper broker: Eightcap would need to average roughly 0.1 pip tighter on EUR/USD to offset the $1.00 commission gap.
Key facts at a glance
- Raw round-turn commission (USD): Eightcap $7.00 ($3.50/side) vs Tickmill $6.00 ($3.00/side) (official broker pages, verified 22 Nov 2026).
- Spread break-even: $1.00 per EUR/USD standard lot equals 0.1 pip — the average spread advantage Eightcap would need to match Tickmill's all-in cost.
- EA policy: Tickmill explicitly confirms EAs on Classic and Raw accounts for MT4/MT5 (not allowed on TradingView Raw); Eightcap's
/en/faqs/includes EA installation instructions and its homepage advertises MT4 24/7 trading robots, though no standalone EA restriction policy was captured (verified 22 Nov 2026). - Triple-swap day: Both list Wednesday for FX; Eightcap lists Friday for stocks, indices, and commodities (and MT4); Tickmill publishes live per-symbol swaps on
/conditions/spreads-swaps(non-FX triple-swap day not stated there). - Referral note: QuantKit has an active disclosed Eightcap referral path below, and no active Tickmill referral link on this page.
How do Eightcap Raw and Tickmill Raw costs compare?
Both brokers are compared on the same instrument (EUR/USD, 1 standard lot = 100,000 units, round turn) and account type (MT5 Raw, USD base) using QuantKit's formula: all-in per lot = average spread (pips) × $10 + round-turn commission. Advertised "from 0.0 pips" floors are never entered as averages.
| Input (EUR/USD, USD account) | Eightcap Raw | Tickmill Raw |
|---|---|---|
| Spread "from" (floor) | 0.0 pips | 0.0 pips |
| Average spread used by QuantKit | Not yet graded (third-party 0.10 pip capture not adopted) | 0.1 pips (grade B+C, ledger v1.0) |
| Commission per side | $3.50 | $3.00 |
| Commission round turn | $7.00 | $6.00 |
| Graded all-in per lot | Not yet graded | $7.00 |
| Minimum deposit | $100 | 100 (account currency) |
Tickmill also offers a TradingView Raw account at $3.50 per side, but its accounts table marks EAs as not allowed, placing it outside MT5 EA scope.
What is the break-even at EA trading volumes?
Commission is confirmed for both brokers, while average spread is graded for Tickmill only. That sets a clear break-even test:
- Commission gap:
$7.00 − $6.00 = $1.00 per lotround turn. - Pip equivalent on EUR/USD:
1 pip ≈ $10per standard lot, so$1.00 = 0.1 pip.
If Eightcap's live EUR/USD spread averages 0.1 pip tighter than Tickmill's during your EA's trading hours, all-in costs tie; any narrower gap leaves Tickmill cheaper, and any wider gap favours Eightcap.
Worked volume example (illustrative commission-only figures): An EA trading 100 lots/month on EUR/USD pays about $100/month more in commission on Eightcap Raw than on Tickmill Raw before spreads; at 5 lots/month, the commission gap is about $5/month. Enter your live observed bid/ask spreads for both brokers into QuantKit's free CFD all-in cost calculator to compare total trade costs side by side.
How do swaps and holding costs compare?
Tickmill publishes live per-symbol spreads and swaps in a tabbed table on Spreads and Swaps (e.g., on 22 November 2026: EURUSD typical spread 0.1, swap long -6.3 / short 3.1; XAUUSD swap long -51.9 / short 36.34), while Eightcap does not publish a static numeric swap table on the pages we fetched. Always confirm live rates in your MT5 symbol specification. Documented rollover schedules compare as follows:
| Holding-cost rule | Eightcap | Tickmill |
|---|---|---|
| When swap applies | Overnight (00:00 NY rollover, FAQ) |
Daily at 00:00 platform time (EU/UK costs pages) |
| Triple-swap day (FX) | Wednesday | Wednesday |
| Triple-swap day (non-FX) | Stocks, indices, commodities on Friday; MT4 triples on Friday (FAQ) | Not published on pages fetched |
| Swap-free option | Islamic accounts with admin charge instead of swap (fee schedule not on pages fetched) | Islamic account: 3 charge-free nights, handling fee from night 4 at 00:00 server time, day-41 exception on Classic Swap-Free for listed JPY/CHF/gold/silver, 5-day then 10%/yr on long crypto CFDs |
For swing or position EAs, overnight financing can exceed round-turn cost within a few nights; see Forex swap and overnight costs explained.
How do EA rules and platforms compare?
| Feature | Eightcap | Tickmill |
|---|---|---|
| MT5 | Yes | Yes (Classic and Raw) |
| Other platforms | MT4, TradingView, TradeLocker (region-dependent) | MT4; Tickmill Trader & TradingView on TradingView Raw |
| EA policy | /en/faqs/ has EA install instructions and homepage advertises MT4 24/7 trading robots; no standalone EA restriction policy captured |
Classic & Raw confirmed (✓ + accounts-overview FAQ on MT4/MT5); trading conditions FAQ supports EAs, scalping, hedging, arbitrage. Not allowed on TradingView Raw |
| VPS | Not published on pages fetched | 20% discount on all packages via BeeksFX (base package pricing / free-VPS threshold not on Tickmill pages) |
| Min lot | 0.01 (confirmed on account-options, trade/eurusd, faqs) |
0.01 |
Two practical checks for EA operators: confirm arbitrage/latency clauses in your onboarding entity's client agreement (QuantKit has not audited Tickmill's client agreement), and ask in writing before running self-copying setups across your own accounts (QuantKit's CFD broker cost study documents an account termination at another broker over MT4-to-MT5 self-copying).
Which legal entity holds your account?
Protections, leverage caps, and fee schedules depend on the onboarding legal entity, not the brand name:
- Tickmill (licences page, verified 22 Nov 2026): Tickmill UK Ltd (FCA
717270, FSCS up to £85,000), Tickmill Europe Ltd (CySEC278/15, ICF 90% up to €20,000), Tickmill Ltd (Seychelles FSASD008; Seychelles page shows up to 1:1000 leverage, which does not apply to UK/EU retail clients), Tickmill South Africa (Pty) Ltd (FSCAFSP 49464), and Tickmill UK Ltd DFSA rep office (F007663). Homepage"FSC Regulated"badge remains unexplained on the licences page. - Eightcap (QuantKit Eightcap review & live pages verified 22 Nov 2026): Eightcap Pty Ltd (ASIC AFSL
391441), Eightcap Group Ltd (FCA FRN921296), Eightcap EU Ltd (CySEC246/14), plus offshore entities in the Bahamas, Seychelles, Mauritius, and St Vincent (the Bahamas client agreement makes negative balance protection discretionary or "where required by law").
What we couldn't confirm
- Eightcap graded EUR/USD average spread: No grade B or adopted grade C average spread is recorded under QuantKit's method yet.
- Eightcap standalone EA restriction policy, VPS terms, numeric swap table, and Islamic admin fee schedule: Not captured on the official pages fetched (Eightcap's dedicated MT4/MT5 platform pages were gated by Vercel Security Checkpoint on 22 Nov 2026).
- Tickmill non-FX triple-swap day, BeeksFX base package pricing/free-VPS threshold, unexplained homepage
"FSC Regulated"badge, and client agreement arbitrage clauses: Not published or reviewed on the pages fetched. - Controlled slippage data: Neither broker publishes controlled slippage benchmarks.
What should you do next?
- Confirm which legal entity will onboard you at each broker and read that entity's fee page.
- Run a 5-day MT5 demo spread log on both brokers during your EA's active hours and plug the results into the CFD all-in cost calculator.
- Compare live symbol swaps in MT5 and ask support in writing about order frequency, hedging, or self-copying.
If you have completed those checks and choose to open an account with Eightcap, this is QuantKit's disclosed referral path (same public price unless Eightcap's terms say otherwise):
QuantKit has no active Tickmill referral link on this page. See /disclosure/ for how QuantKit is paid.
FAQ
Is Eightcap or Tickmill cheaper for MT5 EAs?
QuantKit cannot name a cheaper broker yet. Tickmill's Raw commission is $6.00 round turn versus Eightcap's $7.00, and Tickmill's graded EUR/USD all-in is $7.00 per lot. Because Eightcap's average spread is not yet graded under QuantKit's method, the test is the break-even: Eightcap needs roughly 0.1 pip tighter average spreads on EUR/USD to match.
What is the Raw commission at Eightcap vs Tickmill?
On a USD Raw account, Eightcap charges $3.50 per side ($7.00 round turn) and Tickmill charges $3.00 per side ($6.00 round turn). Tickmill's TradingView Raw account is $3.50 per side, but EAs are not allowed on it.
Does Tickmill allow Expert Advisors on MT5?
Yes. Tickmill's accounts overview confirms Classic and Raw with checkmarks (✓) and FAQ text for MT4/MT5 EAs, and its trading conditions FAQ states it fully supports EAs, scalping, hedging, and algorithmic trading. TradingView Raw does not allow EAs.
Does Eightcap allow Expert Advisors?
Eightcap's /en/faqs/ page includes instructions for installing MT4/MT5 Expert Advisors and its homepage advertises MT4 24/7 trading robots, though QuantKit did not capture a standalone EA restriction policy page (verified 22 November 2026). Confirm directly with Eightcap for your strategy before depositing.
When is triple swap charged at Eightcap and Tickmill?
Both brokers list Wednesday for FX pairs. Eightcap states that stocks, indices, and commodities (and MT4 symbols) triple on Friday; Tickmill's non-FX triple-swap day was not published on the pages we fetched.
Why is Eightcap's all-in cost not graded yet?
QuantKit's published methodology requires an accepted average spread (grade B broker-published or adopted grade C). An advertised 0.0 pip floor is not an average, and a third-party 0.10 pip capture has not been adopted into the ledger.
Sources and method
- Eightcap: Account Options, Trade EURUSD, Traders Homepage, FAQs, About Us, and QuantKit Eightcap review (verified 22 Nov 2026).
- Tickmill: Accounts overview, Spreads and Swaps, Islamic Account, EU trading costs & fees (
?redir=0), UK trading costs & fees, Trading conditions FAQ, Licences and regulation, VPS FAQ, and VPS page (verified 22 Nov 2026). - QuantKit: CFD broker cost ledger (v1.0, 15 Oct 2026), Methodology, and Corrections log.
Related research
- Tickmill review for MT5 Expert Advisors
- Eightcap review: costs, platforms and entities
- What CFD brokers really cost: verified all-in cost per lot
- CFD all-in cost calculator
- Forex swap and overnight costs explained
Disclosure: The marked Referral link for Eightcap on this page may earn QuantKit an IB rebate or affiliate commission; QuantKit has no active Tickmill referral link on this page. See /disclosure/ for rates and rules. Cost figures, grades and wording are not adjusted for partners.
Risk warning: Trading CFDs on margin carries a high risk of loss. Volume examples are illustrations only, not forecasts. Past performance is not indicative of future results. This is not financial advice.
Get new research by email
Dated broker and prop data, plus notes on new tools. No spam. Unsubscribe any time.
You will get an email to confirm. Emails are sent via Buttondown; see the privacy page.